1 (1) ~(~((P & ~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P))) v (~P & ~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)))) -> Q) A 1 (2) ~((P & ~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P))) v (~P & ~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)))) & ~Q 1->R 1 (3) ~((P & ~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P))) v (~P & ~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)))) 2&B 1 (4) ~Q 2&B 1 (5) ~(P & ~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P))) & ~(~P & ~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P))) 3 De Morgan 1 (6) ~(P & ~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P))) 5&B 1 (7) ~(~P & ~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P))) 5&B 1 (8) ~~P v ~~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)) 7 De Morgan 9 (9) ~~P A 9 (10) P 9DN 1 (11) ~P v ~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)) 6 De Morgan 12 (12) ~P A 12,9 (13) ~P & P 12,10&E 14 (14) ~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)) A 14 (15) (Q & P) v (~Q & ~P) 14DN 16 (16) Q & P A 16 (17) Q 16&B 16 (18) P 16&B 16,1 (19) Q & ~Q 17,4&E 16,1 (20) ~P & P 19 e.f.q. 21 (21) ~Q & ~P A 21 (22) ~Q 21&B 21 (23) ~P 21&B 21,9 (24) ~P & P 23,10&E 21,9 (25) ~P & P 24 e.f.q. 14,1,9 (26) ~P & P 15,16,20,21,25vB 1,9 (27) ~P & P 11,12,13,14,26vB 28 (28) ~~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)) A 28 (29) ~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)) 28DN 28 (30) ~(Q & P) & ~(~Q & ~P) 29 De Morgan 28 (31) ~(Q & P) 30&B 28 (32) ~(~Q & ~P) 30&B 28 (33) ~~Q v ~~P 32 De Morgan 34 (34) ~~Q A 34 (35) Q 34DN 34,1 (36) Q & ~Q 35,4&E 34,1 (37) ~P & P 36 e.f.q. 38 (38) ~~P A 38 (39) P 38DN 28 (40) ~Q v ~P 31 De Morgan 41 (41) ~Q A 1 (42) ~P v ~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)) 6 De Morgan 43 (43) ~P A 43,38 (44) ~P & P 43,39&E 43,38 (45) ~P & P 44 e.f.q. 46 (46) ~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)) A 46 (47) (Q & P) v (~Q & ~P) 46DN 48 (48) Q & P A 48 (49) Q 48&B 48 (50) P 48&B 48,41 (51) Q & ~Q 49,41&E 48,41 (52) ~P & P 51 e.f.q. 53 (53) ~Q & ~P A 53 (54) ~Q 53&B 53 (55) ~P 53&B 53,38 (56) ~P & P 55,39&E 53,38 (57) ~P & P 56 e.f.q. 46,41,38 (58) ~P & P 47,48,52,53,57vB 1,41,38 (59) ~P & P 42,43,45,46,58vB 60 (60) ~P A 60,38 (61) ~P & P 60,39&E 60,38 (62) ~P & P 61 e.f.q. 28,1,38 (63) ~P & P 40,41,59,60,62vB 28,1 (64) ~P & P 33,34,37,38,63vB 1 (65) ~P & P 8,9,27,28,64vB (66) ~~(~((P & ~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P))) v (~P & ~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)))) -> Q) 1,65RAA (67) ~((P & ~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P))) v (~P & ~~((Q & P) v (~Q & ~P)))) -> Q 66DN