V-dogg's version + _cheerios addition of : =========================================================== reply[usertext] You have not entered enough text into the reply edit box, it must contain as least 2 characters You have exceeded the character limit allowed to be submitted by a reply, it must not be more then 5000 characters 1 5000 REPLY ======== array 0 => array 'message' => string '' (length=0) 'errors' => array 0 => string 'reply[usertext]' (length=15)