SELECT ufirstname,class_time_r.tid FROM users LEFT JOIN class_user_r ON users.uid=class_user_r.uid LEFT JOIN class_time_r ON class_user_r.cid=class_time_r.cid WHERE ufirstname='Connie' ORDER BY tid DESC; +------------+------+ | ufirstname | tid | +------------+------+ | Connie | 20 | | Connie | 19 | | Connie | 18 | | Connie | 17 | +------------+------+