From Problem host
****************
traceroute to theorem.servebeer.com (72.76.251.148), 64 hops max, 40 byte packets
 1  openwrt (192.168.1.1)  0.902 ms  0.533 ms  0.518 ms
 2  10.240.176.17 (10.240.176.17)  282.772 ms  252.286 ms *
 3  dstswr1-vlan2.rh.nbrgnj.cv.net (67.83.246.161)  281.879 ms * *
 4  rtr1-ge1-14.mhe.prnynj.cv.net (67.83.246.129)  184.230 ms *  277.921 ms
 5  rtr4-tg11-2.wan.prnynj.cv.net (64.15.6.25)  331.878 ms  250.384 ms *
 6  64.15.0.65 (64.15.0.65)  271.912 ms  286.313 ms  200.414 ms
 7  64.15.0.38 (64.15.0.38)  239.509 ms  239.067 ms  232.556 ms
 8  * * *
 9  *
    so-7-1-0-0.BB-RTR1.NY325.verizon-gni.net (130.81.17.128)  273.685 ms *
10  so-7-2-0-0.BB-RTR1.NY5030.verizon-gni.net (130.81.7.90)  233.200 ms  210.092 ms  178.555 ms
11  130.81.19.97 (130.81.19.97)  252.648 ms  250.252 ms  312.313 ms
12  P11-0.LCR-02.NWRKNJ.verizon-gni.net (130.81.29.191)  243.014 ms  288.773 ms *
13  P0-0.VFTTP-11.NWRKNJ.verizon-gni.net (130.81.38.209)  252.824 ms *  209.115 ms
14  pool-72-76-251-148.nwrknj.fios.verizon.net (72.76.251.148)  278.714 ms  255.442 ms *

To Problem Host
******************
.oO(theorem@routerbox ~) traceroute 67.81.176.10
traceroute to 67.81.176.10 (67.81.176.10), 64 hops max, 40 byte packets
 1  10.5.35.15 (10.5.35.15)  5.371 ms  5.352 ms  5.828 ms
 2  P3-2.LCR-01.NWRKNJ.verizon-gni.net (130.81.38.192)  5.808 ms  5.438 ms  5.834 ms
 3  so-6-0-0-0.PEER-RTR1.NWK80.verizon-gni.net (130.81.17.157)  5.835 ms  7.654 ms  63.845 ms
 4  451be0e5.cst.lightpath.net (65.19.113.229)  7.806 ms  7.671 ms  7.843 ms
 5  rtr4-tg9-1.wan.prnynj.cv.net (64.15.0.81)  25.830 ms  213.558 ms  211.776 ms
 6  rtr2-tg10-2.mhe.prnynj.cv.net (64.15.6.30)  9.834 ms  9.907 ms  9.599 ms
 7  ool-4353f68e.dyn.optonline.net (67.83.246.142)  11.836 ms  11.577 ms  11.907 ms
 8  ubr103-fa1-0.cmts.nbrgnj.cv.net (67.83.246.173)  12.095 ms  11.715 ms  9.849 ms
 9  ool-4351b00a.dyn.optonline.net (67.81.176.10)  285.623 ms *  198.521 ms